Cast Party: Who Should Star In A ‘Goldie Vance’ Movie?

Shahidi's already a breakout star at such a young age, making a name for herself on Black-ish. This would be a perfect vehicle for her.

McClain will be a great contrast to Shahidi as Goldie's more grounded best friend.

Hemsworth showed such comedic potential in Ghostbusters that I really want him to do more with that. He'll be a lot smarter in this movie, but still pretty goofy.

The best possible Rob would be a time-displaced Fresh Prince-era Alfonso Ribeiro. But in his absence, Brooks will do a fine job.

I think Foxx is at his best when he plays characters with some warmth at their core, which will make him great as Mr. Vance.

Hendrix rose to fame as a '60s beauty for the 21st Century, which makes her ideal for Goldie's mom, an occasional mermaid.

Cut Steinfeld's hair and give her that beatnik glamour, and she'll be a perfect love interest.

He already looks like him, just give him that skunk stripe and he's ready to go.

There's a lot we don't know yet about Sugar's deal, but if Shipka proved one thing on Mad Men, it's that she can handle anything you throw at her.

Odenkirk looks nothing like the Maple from the comics, but he's one of the best at yelling at people, which is what really matters for this role, I think.