Contact Us

The Animated Oscars: What If the Academy Truly Honored Cartoons?


From Moviefone: There’s still a weird, ignorant stigma that animation is just kids’ stuff, but oftentimes, it is just as captivating, impressive and entertaining as any live-action movie. You want proof? Check out what we named as the best movie of 2010.

This year, three movies will compete for the Academy Award for Best Animated Feature. And while all three movies are worthy of praise, we can’t help feeling that the Oscars could have done more. The award for Best Animated Feature didn’t begin until 2001, and due to the way the rules are structured, usually only three movies get acknowledged. That just isn’t enough.

We thought it was time to honor the impact animation has made in the world of film, with a fun look at what could have been. In our alternate history, beloved classics, genius voices and the kings of animation would have been receiving awards for decades, side by side with their “real” counterparts. To see how different the world of movies could have been, check out our list of animation history’s Oscar winners.

THE RULES
Imagine a world where animation could receive Oscars for (voice) acting, direction and writing. We tried to make it as simple as possible, and hold the cartoons to the same eligibility rules as live-action films. The following list presents highlights in each category, from each decade in our alt-history.

BEST ANIMATED FEATURE

‘Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs’ (1937)
The animated Oscars came into play at the 1938 Academy Awards, honoring the release of Disney’s pioneering fairy tale feature, the first full-length animated film. With men like Walt Disney, Max Fleischer and Friz Freleng pushing animators to innovate at studios ranging from MGM to Paramount to Warner Bros., the Academy deemed it necessary to acknowledge the creative work of all those in the animation field.

‘Fantasia’
(1940)

‘Fantasia’ would beat out fellow Disney film ‘Pinocchio’ for the top award. The dazzling collection of images with classical music, from the work of Disney’s top animators, would be indicative of the studio’s grip on these early Oscars. Disney would receive Best Picture honors for films like ‘Dumbo,’ ‘Bambi’ and so on.

‘Sleeping Beauty’ (1959)
‘Beauty’ would mark a stylistic departure for Disney, featuring incredibly lavish painterly designs. Due to ‘Beauty”s elaborate goals, it became the most expensive film in the studio’s history up to that point. And while it would win our award for Best Feature, it also underperformed at the box office, contributing to Disney’s declining profits; as they were forced to begin laying off animators and cutting budgets — and after Walt Disney passed away — the quality of Disney films would slowly begin to slip and they would no longer remain as dominant at the animated Oscars.

‘The Phantom Tollbooth’ (1970)
Chuck Jones still stands as an influential figure, thanks to his pioneering visual efforts, in the world of the Looney Tunes. ‘Tollbooth,’ the first feature-length film he produced (and co-directed with Abe Levitow and Dave Monahan), would provide the Academy with another chance to reward his entire filmography. Additionally, an Oscar victory for this adaptation of the clever children’s classic would give veteran voice actors like Mel Blanc, Daws Butler and Thurl Ravenscroft another notch in their belts, as the three men alone voiced over half a dozen characters between them.

‘Fritz the Cat’ (1972)
‘Midnight Cowboy’ became the first X-rated movie to win the Best Picture Oscar and ‘Fritz the Cat’ would soon follow suit, as not only the first X-rated cartoon, but also the first X-rated cartoon to win an Oscar. The adaptation of underground comic legend R. Crumb’s satire, starring a neurotic, anthropomorphic feline, shocked and titillated audiences with its send-up of the sex-and-drug-filled counter-culture. The film marked the feature debut of Ralph Bakshi, an alternative-skewed animator who reigned for two decades afterward, creating acid-like sci-fi and fantasy (including a ‘Lord of the Rings’ adaptation) and scathing social parody. The film divided critics and Crumb himself disowned it, but ‘Fritz’ had an immediate impact signifying the changing voices in animation.

‘Watership Down’ (1978)
This British production came from an adaptation of the best-selling fantasy novel, an allegorical tale about a society of rabbits searching for peace in a world filled with animal bloodshed. ‘Watership Down’ resonated with audiences upon its release, thanks to its lush water-colored design and realistic characters. The film not only shocked viewers with its depictions of brutal violence in the animal kingdom, but also displayed a mystic, lyrical atmosphere.

‘The Secret of NIMH’ (1982)
At a time when Disney was suffering from a creative lull, ‘NIMH’ swooped in and provided a new voice to the world of animation, offering up this fantastical tale of a widowed field mouse who must find a cure for her son’s illness before their home is destroyed. The movie also marked the feature-length directorial debut of Don Bluth, a Disney expatriate who tirelessly worked to eschew cheaper animation techniques, in favor of developing ‘NIMH’ in a classical animation style. ‘NIMH”s hypothetical Oscar victory would provide healthy competition to Disney for the remainder of the 80s.

‘Beauty and the Beast’ (1991)
You might recall that ‘Beast’ became the first animated feature to be nominated for Best Picture, but in our animated Oscar world, that was just one of many accolades bestowed upon the film. In addition to being a worldwide blockbuster, the film’s combination of technical wizardry with brilliant story telling would push it to dominate that year’s animated Academy Awards. It served as one of many highpoints in Disney’s 90s renaissance.

‘Toy Story’ (1995)
Everything that could be said about the impact of ‘Toy Story’ and Pixar has already been said, but by winning our animated Oscar, perhaps audiences would have sooner realized that the story of Buzz Lightyear and Woody the Cowboy was a wonderful peak in our collective artistic experience. By being both modern and American, and timeless and universal at the same time, ‘Toy Story’ was not just Pixar’s debut feature, but a new addition to the world’s collection of fairy tales.

‘Toy Story 2′ (1999)
And the second installment would go on to do more of the same. In our fictional history, ‘Toy Story 2′ would do what only ‘The Godfather II’ could do before it: become a Best Picture-winning sequel. Now that it looks like ‘Toy Story 3′ is poised to win the Academy Award this year, imagine a world where each part of the ‘Toy Story’ journey was rewarded with a deserving Oscar. Not even the ‘Godfather’ series could culminate in as satisfying a note.


BEST VOICE ACTOR
Phil Harris as Balloo the Bear in ‘The Jungle Book’ (1967)
A man of many talents — from big band singer to actor to radio comedian opposite Jack Benny — the barrel-toned Harris would be honored for his distinctly joyous and lovable work as the carefree bear who performs the movie’s most lasting musical number.
Robin Williams as the Genie in ‘Aladdin’ (1992)
The manic comedian took what should have been a traditional supporting player and turned the magical character into a dominating, scene-controlling force of nature. Disney took a big chance by allowing Williams to improvise and ad-lib during voice recording sessions. The Academy would reward such an usual departure for animated films with an Oscar win.
Tom Hanks as Woody in ‘Toy Story’ (1995)
‘Toy Story’ would sweep all the major awards, and Hanks would rack up yet another Oscar for his acting talents, leaving an impact with just his voice.

Johnny Depp as Victor Van Vort in ‘Corpse Bride’ (2005)

Depp has become one of the Academy’s oft-nominated, never-won actors, but this animated team-up with director Tim Burton, his most successful creative collaboration, would finally provide Depp with another opportunity to indulge in his own off-beat mannerisms and finally earn some kudos.

George Clooney as Mr. Fox in ‘Fantastic Mr. Fox’ (2009)
The charming, fast-talking schemer in the unique adaptation of the Roald Dahl classic finally gave Clooney some award recognition as a leading man, and also gave director Wes Anderson another avenue to display his talents at orchestrating a comedic ensemble.



BEST VOICE ACTRESS
Adriana Caselotti as Snow White in ‘Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs’ (1937)
Walt Disney signed the opera-trained singer to a studio contract to prevent her from performing elsewhere and spoiling the illusion of Snow White’s voice. As her only credited screen performance, the connection between her voice and the fairy tale character were inseparable, giving her an Oscar win.

Kathryn Beaumont as Alice in ‘Alice in Wonderland’ (1951)

Walt Disney personally cast Beaumont to star in his long-desired, madcap adaptation of the Lewis Carroll classic. At 13-years-old, she became the youngest woman to win the Best Voice Actress Award.

Junko Iwao as “Mima Kirigoe” in ‘Perfect Blue’ (1997)

While critics are raving this year about Natalie Portman’s performance in ‘Black Swan,’ Satoshi Kon’s anime thriller told a similar story 13 years prior. As the pop star Mima gives up the music world to pursue acting, she quickly finds herself stalked by a ominous stranger. Soon Mima begins to lose her grip on reality, unsure who to trust, and finds herself mysteriously connected to the dangers around her. Iwao’s portrayal of a young woman on the verge of a breakdown was so unnervingly effective that the Academy awarded her with the Oscar, making her the first Asian woman to win the award and the first foreign-language-speaking recipient as well.

Ellen DeGeneres as Dory in ‘Finding Nemo’ (2003)

Like Robin Williams before her, DeGeneres took what should have been a supporting part and commandeered each scene she appeared in; by using her hilariously genial approach to such a broad character — a fish with frustrating short-term memory — she infused Dory with genuine sweetness.

Janeane Garofalo as Colette Tatou in ‘Ratatouille’ (2007)

The acerbic, dry comedian was provided with an opportunity to step outside her usual range of screen types and deliver an energized screwball performance that delighted Academy members, who were not afraid to reward a performance that made them laugh.


BEST FOREIGN LANGUAGE ANIMATED FEATURE
‘Fantastic Planet’s’ psychedelic, surrealist sci-fi parable served as a perfect model for all the amazing animation work being produced around the world. The pure vision of French artists Rene Laloux and Roland Topor has remained colorfully captivating and thematically entrancing for almost 40 years.

‘Grave of the Fireflies’ (1988)

Anime has impacted not just the world of international animation, but all of pop culture. And 1988 would have proven to be a banner year for the Japanese art form; Academy voters had the chance to acknowledge the ground-breaking, cyberpunk thriller ‘Akira’ or the blockbuster phenomenon ‘My Neighbor Totoro’ (which launched a globally iconic cartoon character). Instead however, they shocked audiences by bestowing the award on the lesser-seen ‘Grave of the Fireflies.’ Telling the story of an orphaned brother and sister trying to survive the fire bombings of Kobe in the last days of WWII, the film’s hauntingly beautiful approach to heartbreaking material demonstrated all the humanistic potential in animation. Roger Ebert has opined that it serves as one of the greatest anti-war movies ever made.

‘Princess Mononoke’ (1997)

In the real world, ‘Mononoke’ became the first anime to win Best Picture at the Japanese Academy Awards and was the nation’s highest-grossing movie (until ‘Titanic’). Unfortunately, it failed to reach a large audience stateside due to a poorly received English dubbing and an almost-spiteful lack of advertising from the Weinstein Brothers. But in our award show, the epic fantasy battle between man and nature would have been given the proper spotlight.

‘The Triplets of Belleville’ (2003)

We remember ‘Belleville’ losing to ‘Finding Nemo’ in 2003, and it looks like Sylvain Chomet’s subsequent film, ‘The Illusionist,’ will have to place runner-up to Pixar again this Sunday. But our animated Oscars found a deserving accolade for this quirky, expressive story of junkyard musician grandmothers, sad cyclists and the Mob. This may end up being the most wordless foreign language winner ever, but when words are spoken, it’s through infectiously-catchy jazz numbers.

‘Paprika’ (2006)

Filmmaker Satoshi Kon developed a following in the world of cinema fairly quickly, captivating audiences with stories that blurred the line between reality and imagination. ‘Paprika’s’ sci-fi tale of a psychiatrist who must prevent thieves from invading people’s dreams offered up a visual cornucopia of trippy, mind-bending imagery. While in the real world, genre fans are upset at ‘Inception’s’ snubbing by the Academy, our animated Oscars rewarded the imaginative material in 2007. Sadly the Oscar victory would be bittersweet, as ‘Paprika’ became Kon’s last finished film before passing away in 2010.

Continue reading the rest of Eric Larnick’s picks at Moviefone

Best of the Web

More From Around the Web

Leave a Comment

It appears that you already have an account created within our VIP network of sites on . To keep your points and personal information safe, we need to verify that it's really you. To activate your account, please confirm your password. When you have confirmed your password, you will be able to log in through Facebook on both sites.

Forgot your password?

It appears that you already have an account on this site associated with . To connect your existing account with your Facebook account, just click on the account activation button below. You will maintain your existing profile and VIP program points. After you do this, you will be able to always log in to http://comicsalliance.com using your Facebook account.

Please fill out the information below to help us provide you a better experience.

Register on Comics Alliance quickly by logging in with your Facebook account. It's just as secure, and no password to remember!

Not a Member? Sign Up Here.

Register on Comics Alliance quickly by logging in with your Facebook account. It's just as secure, and no password to remember!